If you refuse paternity testing of a minor child in South Africa, the court may draw an adverse inference from that refusal, treating it as support for the other party’s case, under section 37 of the Children’s Act 38 of 2005. Nobody can be physically forced to give a blood or DNA sample, but refusal can cost you the case, a costs order, and, in maintenance or parental rights disputes, the outcome itself.
Paternity testing of a child also needs consent, and not just yours. A minor child who is old and mature enough to understand must consent personally, and a parent or guardian must consent to the sample being taken. That is why refusals happen on both sides: mothers refusing on the child’s behalf, and men refusing to submit their own samples.
This guide sets out what the law allows, what a refusal actually triggers in court, and the mistakes that turn a manageable dispute into a lost one.
How the Law Regulates Paternity Testing
Paternity is usually challenged in three settings: maintenance enquiries under the Maintenance Act 99 of 1998, parental rights and contact disputes under the Children’s Act, and care or guardianship proceedings in the Children’s Court or High Court.
Section 36 of the Children’s Act 38 of 2005 creates a rebuttable presumption of paternity in defined circumstances, for example where the man was in a relationship with the mother at conception or acknowledged paternity. Section 37 then deals with proof: where paternity is challenged, a court may order scientific testing, including a DNA test.
Consent is layered. The child must consent if of an age, maturity and stage of development to understand the implications, and the parent or guardian must consent to the sample being taken from the child. Testing a child without the required consent is unlawful, whatever the dispute between the adults.
What an Unreasonable Refusal Triggers
The central consequence is the adverse inference. When a party refuses to submit to testing, or refuses to make the child available, the court may infer that the refusal supports the other side’s case. The inference is rebuttable, which means you can still lead other evidence, but you start with the deck stacked against you.
| Scenario | Likely legal consequence |
|---|---|
| A man denies paternity but refuses to be tested | Court may apply the section 36 presumption plus the section 37 adverse inference, and confirm paternity on the papers |
| A mother refuses to let the child be tested | Court may draw the inference against her, and the alleged father’s case is strengthened |
| Either party ignores a court order for testing | Contempt proceedings, adverse costs, and the court deciding on the remaining evidence |
| Testing done secretly, without proper consent | Results may be inadmissible or given little weight, and the party risks a costs censure |
| Refusal in a maintenance enquiry | Maintenance court may still declare the man the father and order maintenance |
Refusal also plays badly outside the courtroom. In care and contact disputes, courts weigh each parent’s conduct. A parent who obstructs a simple, safe test that would end the uncertainty is often seen as acting against the child’s best interests.
The Best-Interests Principle
Section 7 of the Children’s Act makes the child’s best interests the paramount concern in every matter concerning the child. Courts approach paternity testing through that lens: knowing one’s biological parentage carries identity, medical and inheritance significance for the child.
A court will therefore scrutinise any refusal that is not grounded in a genuine concern for the child’s welfare, such as a medical risk or the child’s own informed objection. Convenience, spite or tactical pressure is not a defensible reason, and litigants who use refusal as a tactic usually pay for it in costs and credibility.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Assuming refusal blocks the case. It does not. The court can proceed on the presumption, the adverse inference and any other evidence, and frequently does.
- Running home DNA kits as proof. Results from unaccredited kits, taken without the other party’s knowledge or proper consent chains, carry little or no weight in court.
- Testing a child without the guardian’s consent. Doing so is unlawful and can undo your own case, even if the science is right.
- Ignoring a court order for testing. A refusal at the door of the laboratory after an order is contempt, with punitive costs a realistic outcome.
- Fighting testing while claiming contact. Courts notice the contradiction of demanding parental rights while blocking the one step that would establish whether you are the parent.
- Overlooking the child’s own view. A child old enough to understand must consent personally. Springing a test on an unwilling teenager helps no one’s case.
Get help with a paternity dispute. Otrebski Attorneys’ family law and child law teams in Sandton act in paternity, maintenance and contact matters across South Africa. Call 060 500 3098 or book an appointment.
Frequently Asked Questions
What happens if a father refuses a DNA paternity test in South Africa?
The court cannot physically force a sample, but under section 37 of the Children’s Act 38 of 2005 it may draw a rebuttable adverse inference that the refusal supports the other party’s case. Combined with the section 36 presumption of paternity, a refusal often results in the court finding the man to be the father and ordering maintenance and costs against him.
Can a mother refuse to have her child DNA tested?
A mother, as guardian, may withhold consent, but a court can order testing if it serves the child’s best interests, and her refusal lets the court draw an adverse inference supporting the alleged father’s case. Obstructive refusal also counts against her in care and contact disputes.
Whose consent is needed to test a minor child for paternity?
The child must consent if of an age, maturity and stage of development to understand the implications of the test, and the parent or guardian must consent to the sample being taken. Testing done without the required consent is unlawful and the results are unlikely to help the party who obtained them.
Can a maintenance court order a man to pay for a child he says is not his?
Yes. If the man denies paternity but refuses scientific testing, the maintenance court can rely on the Children’s Act presumption of paternity and the adverse inference drawn from his refusal, and still declare him the father and order maintenance. Refusing the test rarely defeats the claim.
Are home DNA test kits accepted in South African courts?
Generally not on their own. Courts prefer results from accredited laboratories carried out under a court order or with documented, lawful consent from everyone required to consent, including the child where the child is mature enough. Privately obtained kit results are usually treated as indicative at best.
Disclaimer. This article is general information, not legal advice. Paternity, consent and maintenance outcomes depend on the facts of each matter. Confirm current requirements with the Children’s Court or Maintenance Court serving you, and consult an admitted attorney before litigating paternity.
Get Legal Help Today
Speak to an Otrebski Attorneys lawyer about your matter, or request an appointment and we will call you back.
☎ Call 060 500 3098WhatsApp Us