Yes. Being married out of community of property does not prevent you from claiming spousal maintenance. Maintenance after divorce is decided under section 7(2) of the Divorce Act 70 of 1979 on the basis of need and the other spouse’s ability to pay, not on the strength of your antenuptial contract. Even a spouse who receives an accrual claim can, in appropriate circumstances, also be awarded maintenance.
What the property regime changes is how the assets are split, not whether a dependent spouse can be supported. Confusing the accrual calculation with the maintenance claim is the single most common error spouses married out of community make.
This article explains the claim, the factors a court weighs, the difference between accrual and maintenance, and the limited role of maintenance waivers.
What Out of Community of Property Actually Means
Spouses married out of community of property have an antenuptial contract, or ANC. There are two versions:
- Without accrual. What is yours stays yours, what is theirs stays theirs, both during the marriage and at divorce.
- With accrual. Each spouse keeps separate estates during the marriage, but at divorce the growth in the two estates since the wedding is shared in proportion to their accrual weights.
Neither version says anything binding about post-divorce maintenance. That is decided separately by the divorce court.
The Law: Section 7(2) of the Divorce Act
Section 7(2) of the Divorce Act 70 of 1979 allows the court, on divorce, to order a spouse to pay maintenance to the other after considering:
- the existing and prospective means of each spouse;
- their earning capacities and financial needs and obligations;
- their ages and the duration of the marriage;
- the standard of living during the marriage; and
- any factor which in the court’s opinion should be taken into account, including conduct that would be inequitable to ignore, and the effect of forfeiture.
Nothing in the section limits the remedy to in-community marriages. A spouse married out of community who sacrificed a career for the household, or who cannot become self-supporting, is exactly the claimant the section exists for.
Accrual and Maintenance Are Different Claims
| Feature | Accrual claim | Spousal maintenance |
|---|---|---|
| Available when | ANC with accrual only | Any marriage regime, including out of community |
| What it pays | A once-off capital share of the growth in the estates | Periodic payments, sometimes with an end date |
| Basis | Arithmetic: the estates’ growth since the wedding | Need, means, and the section 7(2) factors |
| Can both be claimed? | Yes. A court can order accrual plus maintenance where the facts justify both | |
Can Maintenance Be Waived in the ANC?
A clause in the antenuptial contract in which each spouse gives up the right to claim maintenance from the other is generally not enforceable on divorce. The Constitutional Court confirmed in VW v HW that an agreement made before the divorce, without the court’s approval, cannot oust the divorce court’s duty to consider maintenance under section 7.
A waiver only truly sticks if it is made an order of court in the divorce itself, with both spouses properly informed. If you signed such a clause years ago, it does not end the enquiry; it is one factor the court will weigh.
Interim, Rehabilitative, and Permanent Maintenance
Three forms of the claim appear in practice:
- Interim maintenance, claimed under rule 43 of the Uniform Rules of Court while the divorce is pending, to keep the household running.
- Rehabilitative maintenance, paid for a defined period while the claimant retrains or re-enters the workplace. This is the most common order today.
- Permanent maintenance, reserved for older spouses, long marriages, or where self-sufficiency is not realistically attainable.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Assuming “out of community” means no maintenance. The ANC governs the assets. Maintenance is a separate statutory claim.
- Trading accrual away for maintenance, or vice versa, without valuation. Each claim has a different value, tax profile, and end date.
- Signing a divorce settlement containing a waiver unthinkingly. Once made an order of court, the waiver is final.
- Claiming only after the divorce. Maintenance is claimed in the divorce action. Later applications need new facts and are far harder.
- Hiding needs evidence. Budgets, payslips, and career sacrifices must be proved, not asserted.
- Ignoring the clean break principle. Courts prefer orders that end dependency, so structure the period and amount realistically.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can you claim spousal maintenance if married out of community of property?
Yes. Your marital property regime does not bar a maintenance claim. Under section 7(2) of the Divorce Act 70 of 1979, the divorce court may order the other spouse to pay maintenance based on need, means, and the listed factors, regardless of whether you were married in or out of community of property.
Can I claim both accrual and spousal maintenance?
Yes. The accrual claim is a once-off capital payment calculated from the growth in the spouses’ estates, while maintenance is a needs-based periodic payment. They are separate remedies, and a South African divorce court can award both where the facts justify it.
Does an antenuptial contract waiver stop a maintenance claim?
Generally no. A maintenance waiver signed in the antenuptial contract before the divorce is not enforceable on its own. The Constitutional Court confirmed in VW v HW that a waiver made without the court’s approval in the divorce cannot prevent the court from considering maintenance under section 7 of the Divorce Act.
How long does spousal maintenance last after divorce?
It depends on the order. Rehabilitative maintenance runs for a fixed period while the recipient retrains or re-enters work, and is the most common form. Permanent maintenance is reserved for long marriages or spouses who cannot realistically become self-supporting. Courts favour orders that eventually end financial dependency.
Get help with a spousal maintenance claim. Otrebski Attorneys’ family law team in Sandton handles maintenance and accrual claims in divorce. Call 060 500 3098 or book an appointment.
Disclaimer. This article is general information about South African family law, not legal advice on a specific marriage or divorce. Maintenance outcomes depend on the facts of each case. Confirm your position with a family law attorney before acting.
Get Legal Help Today
Speak to an Otrebski Attorneys lawyer about your matter, or request an appointment and we will call you back.
☎ Call 060 500 3098WhatsApp Us