The main disadvantage of marriage out of community of property is that each spouse keeps their own estate, so a spouse who earns less, or who gave up a career for the household, can leave the marriage with far less than the other. Other drawbacks include financial inequality between spouses during the marriage, no automatic right to the other’s assets, the cost of the antenuptial contract, and complex accrual calculations at divorce.
Out of community of property is not a bad choice. It protects a spouse from the other’s debts and suits business owners and second marriages. But it trades protection for separation, and the disadvantages below are what couples discover only when it is too late to change.
No Automatic Sharing at Divorce
The hardest disadvantage appears at divorce. Married out of community without accrual, each spouse keeps exactly what they own, and there is no sharing, no matter how long the marriage lasted or how the responsibilities were divided. A spouse who raised children while the other built a practice or a business can end the marriage with little to nothing in their own name.
Divorce courts can order spousal maintenance in suitable cases under the Divorce Act 70 of 1979, but maintenance is discretionary, often temporary, and never guaranteed. It does not compare with the automatic 50/50 sharing that in community of property provides.
Unequal Financial Power During the Marriage
Separate estates mean separate money. The higher-earning spouse can invest, buy property, and build wealth entirely in their own name, while the other spouse has no legal claim on any of it. Where one spouse controls the finances, the other can spend years financially dependent without realising how exposed they are.
This also affects household decisions. A spouse whose name is not on the bond, the business, or the investments has less bargaining power in practice, whatever the marriage is like emotionally.
Financial Secrecy Is Easier
In community of property forces a degree of transparency, because major transactions need the other spouse’s written consent. Out of community, each spouse can incur debt, sign sureties, buy, and sell without telling the other. Hidden debts do not bind the other spouse’s estate, but hidden assets also stay hidden, and discoveries at divorce are common.
The Accrual Claim Has Its Own Problems
Most out of community marriages include accrual, which shares the growth in the estates at divorce. Accrual fixes some of the unfairness, but it brings its own complications.
- Commencement values matter. An estate’s starting value is recorded in the ANC. Where it was overstated, or assets were omitted, the eventual accrual claim shrinks.
- Complex calculations. Inheritances, legacies, and donations are excluded from accrual, but proving what was inherited, and tracing it through years of spending and investment, is expensive and disputed.
- Assets can be dissipated. A spouse who dissolves or moves assets before divorce forces costly forensic work to quantify the claim.
- Delay in payment. An accrual claim is a debt, not an immediate transfer. Where the wealthy spouse’s money is tied up in a business, the claim can take years to realise.
Practical and Emotional Drawbacks
| Disadvantage | What it means in practice |
|---|---|
| Cost of the ANC | A notary must draft and register the contract before the wedding, adding legal fees and timing pressure |
| Perceived lack of trust | One spouse may read the request for an ANC as planning for the marriage to fail |
| Joint purchases get complicated | Homes, vehicles, and household assets bought together need co-ownership paperwork to be enforceable |
| Credit applications | The lower-earning spouse may qualify for less credit alone, while the richer spouse’s estate stands apart |
| Estate planning friction | Wills, life policies, and retirement fund nominations need careful alignment with the accrual arrangement |
| No help with the other’s creditors, either | Protection runs both ways: a spouse in trouble cannot rely on the joint estate to absorb a crisis |
When the Disadvantages Outweigh the Benefits
Out of community without accrual is hardest on a spouse who has no independent income, who interrupted a career, or who expects to contribute to the household rather than to a career. It suits couples where both spouses already have established, comparable estates. Where one spouse is clearly the wealth-builder, accrual is the fairer form of out of community marriage, because it shares the growth while still keeping the estates separate during the marriage.
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Signing the ANC without understanding it. Many spouses discover only at divorce that the contract excluded accrual entirely.
- Leaving the commencement value vague. Inserting a token figure, or none, invites disputes about the estate’s starting point years later.
- Assuming the house is half yours. A home registered in one spouse’s name remains that spouse’s asset, however much the other contributed, unless co-ownership is documented or accrual applies.
- Not updating the ANC discussion. Circumstances change. A couple who chose exclusion when both worked may need to reconsider, by court application under section 21 of the Matrimonial Property Act, when one spouse stops working.
- Confusing funeral and inheritance expectations with the regime. Out of community does not disinherit a spouse; the law of intestate succession still applies. But it does affect what there is to inherit.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the disadvantages of marriage out of community of property?
The main disadvantages are no automatic sharing of assets at divorce, financial dependence for the lower-earning spouse, easier financial secrecy, the cost of the antenuptial contract, and complex accrual calculations where accrual applies. A spouse who gave up a career can end a long marriage with little in their own name.
Does out of community of property protect you from your spouse’s debts?
Yes. Each spouse keeps a separate estate, so one spouse’s creditors cannot attach the other spouse’s assets, unlike in community of property where the joint estate is exposed. The protection works in reverse too, so a spouse in financial trouble cannot rely on the other’s estate.
What happens to a house bought during an out of community marriage?
The house belongs to the spouse in whose name it is registered, unless both are registered or a co-ownership agreement exists. Where accrual applies, the house forms part of that spouse’s estate growth and is shared through the accrual claim at divorce.
Is out of community with accrual better than without accrual?
For most couples, yes. Accrual keeps the estates and debts separate during the marriage but shares the growth in the estates at divorce, protecting a spouse who earned less or supported the household. Without accrual there is no sharing at all, however long the marriage lasted.
Disclaimer. This article is general information, not legal advice for a specific matter. Confirm your own position against your antenuptial contract and the Matrimonial Property Act 88 of 1984, and consult an admitted attorney before deciding. Otrebski Attorneys’ family law department in Sandton drafts antenuptial contracts and advises on matrimonial property regimes.
Get Legal Help Today
Speak to an Otrebski Attorneys lawyer about your matter, or request an appointment and we will call you back.
☎ Call 060 500 3098WhatsApp Us